StartFragment
Getting a customer to place their first order is only the beginning.
The real opportunity starts after they have tried your food, experienced your service and decided whether they would order again.
Many restaurants spend heavily on delivery marketplaces, paid advertising and introductory discounts to attract new customers. But once the order is completed, they do very little to continue the relationship.
The customer disappears until they happen to remember the restaurant again.
A better restaurant marketing strategy gives customers a reason to return and makes their next order easier. Loyalty rewards, email campaigns and push notifications can work together to create that strategy.
The goal is not to send customers more messages.
It is to send the right message, to the right customer, at the right moment.
Why Repeat Restaurant Orders Matter
A first-time customer does not yet have a strong relationship with your restaurant.
They may have discovered you through:
- Social media
- A delivery marketplace
- A recommendation
- A local advertisement
- A promotional discount
After the first order, several things can happen.
The customer may remember your food and return. They may forget your restaurant completely. They may open a delivery marketplace and choose whichever restaurant appears first. They may also choose a competitor offering a larger discount.
You cannot control every decision. But you can improve the likelihood of another order.
A strong retention strategy helps your restaurant:
- Stay visible after the first purchase
- Reward customers for returning
- Promote relevant menu items
- Fill quieter ordering periods
- Build direct customer relationships
- Reduce dependence on marketplace discovery
- Recognise loyal customers
- Win back customers who have stopped ordering
OrderAppsbrings loyalty rewards, email marketing, push notifications and direct online ordering into the same restaurant platform. It is designed to help restaurants communicate with customers directly and encourage more repeat orders.
Repeat Orders Start with a Good First Experience
No loyalty programme can repair consistently poor service.
Before sending promotional campaigns, make sure the customer’s first experience gives them a reason to return.
Check the basics:
- Was the food prepared correctly?
- Did it arrive at the expected time?
- Was the order complete?
- Was the packaging suitable?
- Was collection straightforward?
- Did the website work properly?
- Were prices and delivery charges clear?
- Was customer support available?
- Did the food match its description?
Marketing may bring a disappointed customer back once, but it will not create genuine loyalty.
Your retention system should strengthen a good customer experience, not attempt to hide a bad one.
Build a Direct Customer Relationship
A restaurant cannot run effective retention campaigns without a way to recognise and contact returning customers.
When customers order directly through your branded website or mobile app, your restaurant can build its own customer database, subject to the customer’s choices and applicable privacy rules.
This can help you understand:
- When customers last ordered
- How frequently they order
- Whether they prefer delivery or collection
- Which location they use
- Whether they have joined your loyalty programme
- Which marketing channels they agreed to receive
- Whether they have stopped ordering
OrderApps states that restaurants using its direct ordering, booking and marketing tools can maintain direct customer relationships and use customer activity to support loyalty and targeted campaigns.
This is different from simply having a list of email addresses.
A useful customer database should help you communicate based on behaviour rather than sending the same promotion to everyone.
How Loyalty, Email and Push Notifications Work Together
These three tools serve different purposes.
Loyalty rewards create motivation
A loyalty programme gives customers a visible reason to return.
The customer knows that another order moves them closer to a reward.
Email provides space for detail
Email works well when you need to explain a new menu, seasonal event, set meal, restaurant story or personalised offer.
Push notifications create immediate visibility
Push notifications appear directly on the customer’s mobile device when they have enabled them through your app.
They are best for short and timely messages.
The strongest restaurant retention strategy does not treat these as three separate tools.
It connects them.
For example:
- A customer places their first direct order.
- They receive loyalty points.
- An email explains how the programme works.
- A push notification later reminds them that the points are available.
- A relevant offer encourages the second order.
- Their next purchase moves them closer to a reward.
Each part supports the next one.
How to Create a Restaurant Loyalty Programme That Works
A loyalty programme should be easy to understand.
Customers should quickly know:
- How they earn rewards
- What the reward is
- How close they are to receiving it
- Where they can use it
- Whether it expires
- Which orders qualify
Complicated rules make the programme feel like work.
Choose the Right Loyalty Structure
Restaurants can use several loyalty models.
Points-based loyalty
Customers earn points when they order.
For example:
Earn one point for every £1 spent.
This works well when average order values vary.
Visit-based loyalty
Customers receive a reward after a certain number of visits or orders.
For example:
Order five times and receive a free main course on your sixth order.
This is simple and familiar.
Item-based loyalty
Customers receive a reward after repeatedly buying a specific product.
For example:
Buy nine coffees and receive the tenth free.
This can work especially well for cafés and bakeries.
Tiered loyalty
Customers unlock better benefits as their spending or order frequency increases.
Possible levels could include:
- Member
- Regular
- VIP
Tiered programmes can make frequent customers feel recognised, but they require clearer communication.
Paid membership
Customers pay a monthly or yearly amount in exchange for benefits such as:
- Free delivery
- Regular discounts
- Priority booking
- Exclusive menu access
- A monthly free item
This model requires a strong customer base and benefits that feel genuinely valuable.
Make the First Reward Achievable
Do not make customers wait months for their first benefit.
The beginning of the programme should create momentum.
You could offer:
- Welcome points after registration
- A bonus after the first direct order
- Double points on the second order
- A small reward after three purchases
- Extra points for app users
The first reward should feel close enough to matter.
Once the customer experiences the benefit, they are more likely to understand the programme’s value.
Reward Behaviour You Want to Encourage
A loyalty programme should support your business goals.
Do not give away rewards without deciding what behaviour they are meant to influence.
You might reward customers for:
- Ordering directly
- Choosing collection
- Ordering during quieter hours
- Trying a new menu category
- Using your restaurant app
- Placing several orders
- Booking directly
- Returning after a long absence
For example, collection orders may cost less to fulfil than delivered orders. Offering extra loyalty points for collection could encourage a more profitable ordering habit.
Avoid Making Every Reward a Discount
Constant discounts can train customers to wait for lower prices.
A reward does not always need to be money off.
Consider:
- A free side
- A complimentary drink
- A menu upgrade
- A birthday dessert
- Early access to seasonal dishes
- Priority table booking
- A members-only item
- Double loyalty points
- Free collection extras
Non-cash rewards may feel valuable while costing the restaurant less than a large percentage discount.
Use Email to Bring Restaurant Customers Back
Email gives you more space than a push notification.
You can include:
- Food photography
- Menu descriptions
- Several products
- Event information
- Restaurant news
- Loyalty balances
- Booking buttons
- Direct ordering links
However, customers will stop paying attention when every email says the same thing.
The purpose of restaurant email marketing is not to fill an inbox. It is to create a relevant reason to order or visit.
Essential Restaurant Email Campaigns
Welcome email
Send this after a customer joins your marketing list or loyalty programme.
Include:
- A friendly introduction
- What type of messages they will receive
- How the loyalty programme works
- Their current reward balance
- A direct ordering button
- A clear unsubscribe option
Do not overload the first email with several competing offers.
First-order follow-up
Send a simple message after the customer’s first completed order.
You could:
- Thank them
- Remind them about loyalty points
- Explain how to order directly next time
- Ask for feedback
- Introduce a related menu category
This email should feel helpful rather than aggressive.
Second-order campaign
The second order is an important step because the customer is beginning to form a habit.
A message could say:
You enjoyed your first order. Your next one brings you closer to a loyalty reward.
Make the ordering link obvious.
New menu announcement
Use email to explain a menu launch properly.
Show a small number of featured dishes rather than displaying the entire menu.
Explain:
- What is new
- Why it was added
- When it is available
- How customers can order it
Seasonal campaign
Promote relevant occasions such as:
- Valentine’s Day
- Mother’s Day
- Ramadan
- Easter
- Christmas
- Summer dining
- Bank holidays
- Local festivals
- Sporting events
Plan these campaigns early. Customers may need time to reserve a table or organise a group order.
Birthday email
A birthday reward can make a customer feel recognised.
Keep the rules simple and provide enough time for the customer to use it.
Loyalty progress email
Remind customers how close they are to a reward.
For example:
You are one order away from your free side.
This works because the message is linked to the customer’s existing progress.
Win-back email
A win-back campaign targets customers who have not ordered recently.
The timing should reflect normal buying behaviour.
A weekly takeaway customer may be considered inactive after several weeks. Someone who visits a fine-dining restaurant every few months should not receive the same schedule.
A good win-back email can include:
- A reminder of what they previously enjoyed
- A new menu item
- A loyalty balance
- A time-limited incentive
- A direct link to order
OrderApps promotes automated email campaigns that can nurture customers, reactivate inactive diners and support repeat ordering.
How to Write Better Restaurant Emails
Use a specific subject line
Weak:
Special Offer Inside
Better:
Your Friday dinner is sorted
Weak:
Restaurant Newsletter
Better:
Three new dishes have arrived
Focus on one primary action
Each email should have one main objective:
- Order now
- Book a table
- View the new menu
- Claim a reward
- Download the app
Too many buttons create hesitation.
Write like a restaurant, not a corporation
Customers want to hear from the people preparing and serving their food.
Use natural language.
Instead of:
We are delighted to announce the launch of our new seasonal culinary offerings.
Write:
Our summer menu is ready, and the grilled sea bass is already becoming a team favourite.
Use real food photography
Show the actual dishes customers can order.
Poor-quality or misleading images can weaken trust.
Make the email mobile-friendly
Many customers will open the email on a phone.
Use:
- Short paragraphs
- Large readable text
- Clear buttons
- Compressed images
- A simple layout
- An ordering page that also works on mobile
How to Use Push Notifications Without Annoying Customers
Push notifications can create immediate attention because they appear on the customer’s device.
That strength can also become their biggest weakness.
A poorly timed notification interrupts the customer. Too many notifications can lead them to disable messages or remove the app.
Use push notifications only when the message is timely and useful.
Good Uses for Restaurant Push Notifications
Limited-time availability
Fresh cinnamon rolls are available until 2 pm today.
Quiet-period promotion
Collect between 3 pm and 5 pm today and earn double points.
Loyalty reminder
You are only 50 points away from your next reward.
Relevant reorder prompt
Ready for your Friday night favourite? Order directly in two taps.
Event announcement
Bookings are now open for our Mother’s Day set menu.
New product launch
Our new spicy chicken burger has landed. Try it tonight.
Win-back reminder
It has been a while. Your loyalty points are still waiting.
Location-specific update
For restaurants with several branches:
Our Manchester lunch menu is available from 12 pm today.
OrderApps offers push notifications through branded restaurant mobile apps and includes automated email and push marketing in its Premium package.
Keep Push Notifications Short
A push notification should communicate one clear idea.
A useful structure is:
Reason + benefit + action
For example:
Rainy evening? Get your favourites delivered. Order now.
Avoid trying to fit a full email into a notification.
The landing page should complete the message after the customer taps.
Do Not Send Every Notification to Every Customer
A customer who always orders vegetarian food should not repeatedly receive promotions for meat dishes.
A customer living outside a branch’s delivery area should not receive a location-specific offer.
Segment push notifications by factors such as:
- Preferred location
- Previous orders
- Dietary category
- Collection or delivery behaviour
- Loyalty level
- Last order date
- App activity
- Typical ordering time
Segmentation makes the message feel more relevant.
Create a Customer Retention Journey
Individual campaigns are useful, but an organised journey is better.
Here is a practical example.
After the First Order
Send:
- Order confirmation
- Thank-you message
- Loyalty points earned
- Clear information about future marketing choices
Do not immediately send several promotional messages.
Two or Three Days Later
Send a helpful follow-up email.
Possible content:
- Thank the customer
- Ask about the experience
- Show their loyalty balance
- Recommend one related item
- Link directly to the ordering page
Before Their Usual Reorder Time
Send a push notification or email based on the customer’s normal pattern.
A Friday evening customer may respond well to a message on Friday afternoon.
A weekday lunch customer may need a reminder before lunchtime.
After the Second Order
Recognise the return.
For example:
Thanks for ordering again. You are now halfway to your next reward.
This reinforces progress without relying on a discount.
When a Reward Is Available
Tell the customer clearly.
Do not make them search through an account to discover it.
Include:
- The reward
- How to use it
- The expiry date
- A direct order button
When the Customer Becomes Inactive
Send a win-back sequence.
A simple sequence might contain:
- A friendly reminder
- A new menu or product update
- A loyalty reminder
- A final limited incentive
Stop the sequence when the customer orders again.
Restaurant Campaign Ideas That Can Generate Repeat Orders
The second-order reward
Give first-time customers a reason to return soon.
Example:
Earn double points on your second direct order within 14 days.
Midweek loyalty boost
Use extra points instead of a large discount.
Example:
Earn twice the usual points every Tuesday.
Favourite-order reminder
Remind customers about something they previously ordered.
Example:
Your usual chicken biryani is only a few taps away.
Only use this when the message is appropriate and based on reliable customer information.
Collection campaign
Encourage collection orders during busy delivery periods.
Example:
Collect directly tonight and receive a free side with orders over £25.
New-customer education
Some customers may not understand why they should order directly.
Explain the benefits:
- Restaurant loyalty rewards
- Exclusive menu items
- Easier reordering
- Direct customer support
- App-only offers
New menu campaign
Send the announcement first to loyal customers.
Early access makes them feel valued.
Weather-related campaign
Use weather only when it naturally connects to your offer.
Examples:
- Hot drinks on a cold morning
- Cold drinks during warm weather
- Delivery on a rainy evening
- Outdoor booking availability in sunshine
Local event campaign
Connect promotions to:
- Football matches
- Concerts
- University events
- Local festivals
- Theatre performances
- Community celebrations
Almost-earned reward
Target customers close to reaching a loyalty milestone.
Example:
One more order unlocks your free dessert.
Lapsed VIP campaign
A previously frequent customer deserves a different message from someone who ordered once.
Recognise the relationship:
We have missed serving you. Your member reward is still available.
How Often Should Restaurants Send Marketing Messages?
There is no perfect frequency for every restaurant.
The right schedule depends on:
- Customer expectations
- Order frequency
- Restaurant type
- Campaign relevance
- Seasonality
- Customer preferences
- Message performance
A café may have customers who buy several times a week. A fine-dining restaurant may see the same customer only a few times a year.
Do not copy the same messaging schedule for both.
Use these principles:
- Send messages because there is something useful to say.
- Reduce frequency when engagement falls.
- Avoid sending multiple promotions on the same day.
- Let customers control their preferences.
- Separate urgent service updates from promotional messages.
- Stop sending to people who opt out.
Protect Your Margin
Retention marketing should increase profitable orders, not merely create more discounted orders.
Before launching an offer, calculate:
Order revenue − food cost − packaging − delivery − payment costs − platform charges − discount = estimated contribution
Then ask:
- Would this customer probably have ordered without the discount?
- Does the reward encourage another profitable behaviour?
- Is the minimum order high enough?
- Does the offer apply to high-margin items?
- Could loyalty points work better than immediate money off?
- Does the promotion encourage direct collection?
- Is the offer limited to a quieter period?
A campaign can produce many orders and still perform poorly if the discount removes most of the remaining margin.
Measure More Than Open Rates
Email opens and notification clicks are useful, but they are not the final goal.
Track business outcomes.
Repeat-order rate
The percentage of customers who place another order within a defined period.
Time between orders
How long customers normally wait before purchasing again.
Direct-order frequency
How often registered customers order through your own website or app.
Loyalty participation
The percentage of eligible customers who join and use the programme.
Reward redemption
How many issued rewards are actually used.
Campaign conversion
How many recipients place an order after receiving a campaign.
Average order value
Whether campaign-driven orders are larger or smaller than normal orders.
Unsubscribe rate
A rising unsubscribe rate may indicate excessive frequency or weak relevance.
Push opt-out rate
If many users disable notifications, review your timing, targeting and message quality.
Win-back rate
The percentage of inactive customers who return after a reactivation campaign.
OrderApps states that its online ordering marketing tools include built-in campaign analytics for monitoring and improving email, promotional and push activity.
Follow UK Marketing and Privacy Rules
Restaurants should not assume that receiving an email address or phone number during an order automatically permits future marketing.
The Information Commissioner’s Office says organisations generally need consent before sending unsolicited electronic marketing to individuals, although a limited existing-customer exception known as the soft opt-in may apply when its conditions are satisfied. Customers must have received a clear opportunity to opt out when their information was collected and in every later message.
Consent should be:
- Freely given
- Specific
- Informed
- Unambiguous
- Separate from accepting general terms
Do not use wording such as:
By placing your order, you agree to receive marketing.
Use an unticked choice such as:
I would like to receive restaurant offers by email.
The ICO also advises asking separately for different communication methods. Someone may agree to email marketing but not text messages or another form of communication. Keep a record of who agreed, when they agreed and how consent was collected.
Promotional push notifications and in-app messages can also fall within direct-marketing rules. A cautious restaurant should obtain a clear opt-in, explain what notifications will contain and make them easy to disable.
When someone unsubscribes or objects, stop marketing to them. The ICO recommends maintaining a suppression or do-not-contact list so their details are not accidentally added back into future campaigns.
Service messages and marketing messages should also be treated differently.
An order confirmation is necessary to complete the service. A message promoting a weekend discount is marketing. Adding promotional content to an operational message may change how it is classified.
Privacy and marketing requirements depend on the exact campaign and customer relationship. Obtain professional legal advice when you are unsure.
Common Restaurant Retention Mistakes
Discounting every week
Customers learn to avoid ordering at full price.
Sending the same campaign to everyone
The message becomes less relevant and easier to ignore.
Hiding loyalty rules
Customers lose trust when rewards are difficult to understand or redeem.
Sending too many push notifications
People disable notifications or delete the app.
Collecting details without clear permission
This creates legal and reputational risk.
Ignoring inactive loyal customers
A formerly frequent customer may be more valuable than a new subscriber who has never ordered.
Promoting unavailable products
Campaigns must stay connected to menu availability.
Sending customers to a poor ordering page
A good message cannot rescue a slow or confusing checkout.
Measuring attention instead of sales
Clicks matter only when they support useful business outcomes.
A 30-Day Restaurant Retention Plan
Week 1: Prepare the foundation
- Review the direct ordering experience.
- Check your customer consent process.
- Define loyalty rules.
- Remove outdated customer information.
- Create useful customer segments.
- Select the metrics you will track.
Week 2: Build essential messages
Create:
- Welcome email
- First-order follow-up
- Loyalty explanation
- Reward notification
- Win-back email
- Short push-notification templates
Week 3: Launch one focused campaign
Choose one objective.
For example:
Encourage customers who ordered once in the last 30 days to place a second direct order.
Do not launch several campaigns at once.
Week 4: Review the results
Measure:
- Orders generated
- Revenue
- Discount cost
- Average order value
- Repeat customers
- Unsubscribes
- Notification opt-outs
- Customer feedback
Keep what worked. Change what did not.
How OrderApps Helps Restaurants Generate Repeat Orders
OrderApps combines direct online ordering with tools designed to help UK restaurants build stronger customer relationships.
Depending on the selected plan, OrderApps provides:
- A branded ordering website
- Branded iOS and Android apps
- Customer loyalty rewards
- Promotional discounts
- Email campaigns
- Push notifications
- Automated win-back offers
- Table reservations
- QR and NFC table ordering
- Customer and campaign analytics
OrderApps promotes a connected approach where ordering, customer activity, loyalty and marketing can be managed through the same platform.
As of July 2026, branded mobile apps and table reservations are included in the Growth and Premium packages. Automated email marketing, push notifications and customer win-back tools are listed under the Premium package, currently advertised at £39.99 per month with a 1.49% transaction charge per order. Businesses should confirm current pricing, payment costs and feature availability before subscribing.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can a restaurant increase repeat orders?
Start by providing a reliable first experience. Then make direct reordering easy, introduce a simple loyalty programme and send relevant messages based on customer behaviour.
Do loyalty programmes work for small restaurants?
They can work well when the reward is clear, achievable and financially sustainable.
A small café may use a simple item-based programme, while a takeaway may use points for direct orders.
Is email or push notification better for restaurants?
They serve different purposes.
Email is better for detailed content, menus and events. Push notifications are better for short, timely reminders. Using both selectively can create a stronger customer journey.
How often should restaurants send emails?
Send emails when there is a relevant reason to contact the customer.
Monitor orders, clicks, unsubscribes and feedback rather than following a fixed schedule copied from another business.
Do customers need a restaurant app to receive push notifications?
App-based push notifications generally require customers to install the restaurant’s app and allow notifications.
OrderApps provides branded iOS and Android mobile apps on its Growth and Premium plans. Automated push marketing is listed as a Premium feature.
Should restaurants offer a discount for every repeat order?
No.
Use loyalty points, free add-ons, menu upgrades, exclusive access and personalised rewards so customers do not become dependent on discounts.
Can restaurants email every previous customer?
Not automatically.
UK restaurants must consider PECR and UK GDPR requirements. Consent or the existing-customer soft opt-in may be needed, and customers must receive a simple way to opt out.
What is a restaurant win-back campaign?
A win-back campaign contacts customers who previously ordered but have become inactive.
It may remind them about loyalty points, introduce new dishes or provide a relevant reason to return.
Final Thoughts
Repeat restaurant orders are not created by sending more promotions.
They come from a good first experience, an easy direct ordering process and communication that respects the customer.
Loyalty rewards give people a reason to return.
Email gives you space to tell a useful story.
Push notifications put timely reminders on the customer’s phone.
When these tools work together, your restaurant can move beyond one-time transactions and build long-term customer relationships.
Keep the programme simple. Personalise where it is useful. Protect your margins. Respect customer choices. Measure actual orders rather than vanity metrics.
The objective is not to make customers feel constantly marketed to.
It is to make your restaurant the easy, familiar choice when they are ready to order again.
Turn First-Time Customers into Regulars with OrderApps
Use your own branded ordering website and mobile apps to reward loyal customers, send targeted campaigns and bring inactive diners back.
Explore OrderApps marketing tools or request a demonstration to see how loyalty, email and push notifications can support your restaurant.
EndFragment
Ready to grow your food business?
Commission-free ordering, branded apps, bookings, and EPOS on one platform.
